beagleton
prev|next 
mullah omar osama bin laden civilians soldiers
Nafron and Mike
I thought it might help. I thought if I laid it all out, if I could visualize the distinctions, the boundaries, I thought I might be able to get some strike-back satisfaction.


Did you?


No.

Maybe you just haven't gotten what you want.

I don't think that's it. Even if I imagine a best case scenario where I'm given indisputable proof of bin Laden's direct responsibility, then we blow him up in a cave, it still doesn't sound good. It still sounds sad and bad.

I think you need to visualize a simplified version of the situation. Emphasize pragmatics over vengeance. Picture some children standing on the edge of the subway platform. Here comes a train, and here comes Osama, sneaking up, sneaking up, intent upon pushing the little children to their deaths under the wheels of the A-train. He lunges! You draw your gun! Bam! Bam! Osama's dead! The children are saved! Bravo!

Hmm. Yes, that helps. But wouldn't it be more fun to lasso him? Lasso him and throw him into the pokey? And what if I shoot him dead then learn that he was developmentally disabled with the IQ of a 3 year old?

But he isn't.

No, but doesn't it feel like that? Doesn't he seem to genuinely believe his professed ideology? I can't help seeing him as a man in the grips of a powerful mental virus. A man with a virus-disabled moral sense.

You're hopeless.


I know.


It would be different if you knew someone who was killed.


Probably.


Why is it shaped like a tank?


That was an accident.

beagleton
prev|next